2497 Windmill Point Lane

About this property

PRIVATE, SWIMMABLE LAKE ERIE WATERFRONT - WINDMILL POINT. A rare chance to own on coveted Windmill Point, where homes are tightly held and rarely sell. In 100 years, only three owners. What sets it apart is the shoreline. The home sits on a natural bedrock shelf that keeps the water clear and clean, with far fewer of the seasonal algae issues common elsewhere on the lake - water you can actually use, not just admire. The original breakwall still stands after a century - a good sign the worst storms pass this stretch by. A rocky shore also stays private: crowds gather on sand, not rock, so your waterfront stays yours, while owners enjoy a designated association sandy beach when they want it. Beautifully restored and modernized while keeping its original charm. Over 3,800 sq ft, insulated throughout for true four-season comfort, quiet, and low energy costs. East and West wings give natural separation - up to 6 bedrooms and 3.5 baths - ideal for extended family, guests, or multi-generational living. The renovated west wing features a showpiece chef's kitchen built for multiple cooks, with a 14 foot quartz island, exposed beams, and a pass-through window onto a screened porch stretching 55+ feet along the lake, shaded by mature trees. A separate 1,250 sq ft structure with full bath and loft suits guests, a studio, or conversion to a garage/workshop. A 20kW whole-home generator keeps lakefront living running through any outage. Owners enjoy private association access to over 1km of shoreline, sunrise-to-sunset views, the Buffalo skyline, Point Abino Lighthouse, and tennis - with 25 acres of protected association land behind that can never be developed. Inside: a stone fireplace with gas insert, home theatre, Andersen windows, and engineered hardwood throughout. A clean-water shoreline and permanent protected views - space to gather, host, and hold for generations. Love where you live, at the water's edge - Windmill Point.