2 Island 1210 N/A

ActiveGeorgian Bay · Baxter113 days on marketMLS® X13000996

$2,495,000

$1,663 / sq ft

Bedrooms5

Bathrooms4

Interior1,500 sq ft

Lot Size1 sq ft

TypeSingle Family Home

ListingFor Sale

Days on Market113

About this property

Carved from granite and framed by windswept pines, this stunning island in Georgian Bay's prized Cognashene area offers 520 feet of pristine shoreline. The custom-built cottage is anchored by vaulted ceilings, a stone fireplace, and expansive windows that bring the Bay into every room. Hickory hardwood runs throughout most of the room. The Muskoka Room, with its pine flooring and retractable Weatherwall windows, provides a seamless transition between indoors and out, perfect for summer evenings or cozy fall afternoons. The open-concept kitchen offers generous prep space and looks out over the water. The main cottage features 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, including a tranquil primary with an ensuite, a guest bedroom with a 2-piece bath, and a third bedroom perfect for teens with a separate entrance, and a 3-piece bath. All bathrooms feature heated tile floors. The 620 sq. ft. guest bunkie provides 2 additional bedrooms, a sitting area, a shared bath, and its own kitchenette, plus a private deck and hot tub for star-filled evenings. Outdoor living is effortless with an 800 sq. ft. partially covered deck offering panoramic Bay views, and a 400 sq. ft. waterside deck with sun from dawn to dusk. Boaters will love the deep-water dockage at the U-shaped floating dock, with quick access to open water. This timeless retreat is designed for a new family's effortless connection to the splendour and serenity of the Bay. A spectacular adjoining vacant lot is also available for those seeking extended privacy or future expansion. Just a 15-minute boat ride from the nearest Honey Harbour marina, yet completely removed from the rhythm of everyday life, this rare island offering is more than a cottage. It is a story waiting to be lived in one of Georgian Bay's most coveted areas. Discover the mystique of Georgian Bay island cottaging, it's unmatched by any other cottage destination.

Features & finishes

Waterfront

View

Fireplace

Air Conditioning

Basement

Property details

MLS® Number	X13000996
Status	Active
Listing Type	For Sale
Property Type	Single Family Home
Interior Size	1,500 sq ft
Lot Size	1 sq ft
Beds / Baths	5 bed · 4 bath
Neighbourhood	Baxter
City	Georgian Bay
Postal Code	P0E 1E0
Province	ON
Listed Date	April 15, 2026
Days on Market	113
Price per Sq Ft	$1,663
Brokerage	Johnston & Daniel Rushbrooke Realty